[REVIEW] The Adventures of Amina Al-Sirafi, by Shannon Chakraborty

(Buy this book here.)

This book is absolutely delightful and this review will do it no justice. You have been warned.

Amina Al-Sirafi is a middle-aged single mother with bad knees who lives in a modest country house and minds her own business.

She was also one of the most fearsome pirates who ever sailed the Indian Ocean, at least until strange magic claimed a beloved crewmember and drove her to retirement on dry land. When a mysterious connection to her past comes calling with a simple but lucrative job, she rounds up her respectably retired former crew and takes to the high seas again, only to find that the stakes are far higher and the reward much more important than anyone expected.

I don’t think I can fit everything I love about this book in this post. It’s funny, it’s magical, it’s heart-in-your-throat thrilling. The adventure is big, the characters lovable, and the villains truly nefarious. There’s magic, romance, monsters, and a villain with a long European name our heroine can’t be bothered learning how to pronounce. It’s everything I want in a historical fantasy adventure and didn’t know already existed.

The book is set in post-Crusades, High Middle Ages Yemen, Oman and Somalia, which is unusual but really shouldn’t be. The time period, its people, and its culture are extraordinarily well-depicted, and I hope that all of the little sequel teasers pan out and we get more of it. These pirates live in a cosmopolitan, multicultural, religiously mixed world, and their story is steeped in mythology and history from the region. It is profoundly satisfying to read this and remember that epic imagination is not culturally limited. Everything is written with an eye for historical detail and the flighty fantastical and it all works together wonderfully.

These are rogues poorly working out redemption through adventure, which means they will cuss, cheat and steal, but finish in time for prayer. They’re raising their kids using the money made from grand larceny on the open seas. They’re also diverse in what I’ve come to think of as a normal way. Amina is a Muslim of what she calls “mixed coastal ancestry”, and her crew includes African Muslims, Arab Christians and at least one South Asian Hindu. The religious pluralism of the world works into the story seamlessly. The book also delves much deeper into sexuality and gender than I think people who are not familiar with Islamic reality would expect. Queer themes, gender difference, and sexuality are mentioned but never equated unnecessarily with sin. Sin, however, is mentioned quite a bit because um, hello? PIRATES. This is a book about pirates and while they’re all quite lovable, they also do dastardly things for treasure, and charm us readers into cheering them on while they do it.

One of the reasons I loved this so much is the fun of discovering the world and the story cold, so I won’t say anymore, although I’m gagging to. There is some interesting author info, though, which I’ll discuss in 5, 4, 3, 2…

This book is so culturally detailed and so deeply authentic in its treatment of Islam, the diversity of Muslim cultures and religious pluralism and secularism in both the present day and the long-ago past. It’s just so wonderfully global that I was very surprised to find out that the author, despite her surname, is an American white woman from New Jersey. She converted to Islam in her teens, married into a family of seeming South Asian descent(going by the name) and apparently studies the region, religion and history. She does it very well. I never had that moment we have all often had where you pause and squint and wonder if someone outside of a culture wrote something just to be cool. I admit to being puzzled and a bit put off when I first Googled her, but this book is so good that I got over it in about 5 pages. Your opinion may differ, but ultimately, this book is a work of cultural appreciation, not appropriation. If you’ve been on this blog awhile you know I have no problem flaming silly white authors when it’s deserved, but that is not at all the case here. This book is good, on its own merits. Go read it.

Good maps, heaps of treasure, and restful shore leave to The Adventures of Amina Al-Sirafi

[REVIEW]Remedies for Disappearing, by Alexa Patrick

(Buy this wonderful book here.)

FINALLY AND AT LAST!

It’s been (rightly) noted that I can be rather hard on Black woman writers. (Apologies to Tiffany D Jackson, Tracey Deonn, Jasmine Mans, and others…) I think it’s because I’m aching for us to truly center ourselves and our experiences as our frame of reference, rather than endlessly spiral into the madness of responding to external prejudices.

This poetry collection satisfies that ache. I feel so seen in these verses, in all my Blackness, in all my womanhood, in all my feminity. I think others will, too. Alexa Patrick does the wonderful thing that all good poets do and magnifies small moments into vast meditations on being, connecting, and feeling. Sharing headphones with a stranger on a bus, being one of the two little Black girls in a ballet class, walking past groups of Black men outside of a grocery store, first kisses, last meetings, auntie gatherings, mother ghosts, proms, seasons, love, sadness – it’s all here. It’s all seen and known and examined and loved and it all makes me feel like this is really the Black girl poetry book I’ve needed for a while.

Particularly notable is a series of poems based on prom stories shared by Black girls from a small Connecticut town. They were gathered on Zoom during 2020, and provide an antidote to the painful erasure many Black girls experience when coming of age in a country that seeks to negatively quantify and deny our womanhood at an early age. These were challenging, but beautifully made. I’ve never seen these feelings and experiences presented so transparently or tenderly, and I’m sure I’ll visit those words again.

Here’s how much I loved this book: I NEVER tag authors in reviews but I feel the need to publicly say: @alexalaurel , you DID this, ma’am! Thank you for the words and the empathy.

A hug for the prom girls, a side-eye for the grocery store brothas, and a smile for the lady in the mirror to Remedies For Disappearing.

[REVIEW] The Cutting Season, by Attica Locke

(Buy this book at the Equal Opportunity Bookshop)

I know I keep saying that thrillers and mysteries are really #notmygenre, but books like this and Razorblade Tears are really trying to change my mind. (Notice that both of these books are blackity-Black. Representation matters!)

Caren Gray is the general manager of the historic Louisiana plantation Belle Vie. She’s also a direct descendant of the enslaved Africans who built its wealth. Now the heirs to that ill-gotten fortune are Caren’s bosses, and she and her young daughter are creating a home steeped in an uncomfortable history on the grounds, a stone’s throw away from the old slave cabins.

That is, until a young Guatemalan cane worker is found dead on the property. What seems to be a senseless tragedy is actually linked to the history of the plantation and the people who lay claim to it, past and present. Economic injustice and human exploitation from the past interweave with the ambitions of the present, and one death points to another, with jarring ramifications across generations.

This book was published in 2012, but it’s still startlingly relevant now. Without giving too many spoilers, much of the plot hinges on revisionist history and narrative control for political reasons, and boy, doesn’t that sound familiar? When this book was written, the USA was still immersed in the hope and idealism of the Obama years but there’s a simmering hurt in this book embodied through Caren that almost feels a bit prescient now.

I’m not giving a lot of details because one of the pleasures of the thriller genre is unwrapping all of the details as you read, and I don’t want to deprive anyone of that. I can say, however, that this book is very well-written. The prose is atmospheric and builds up a slow, uneasy suspense without sacrificing beautiful imagery or wordplay like a lot of thrillers do. (At least, according to my stereotypes of the genre, which admittedly may be a bit unfair.)

This was a rare summer read for me–enjoyable, easy, but also very thought-provoking and immersive.

Accurate records and true justice to The Cutting Season.

(Fellow readers, this book is one of the reasons you should be reading the backlist, which is something I should really write a whole post about. I’m glad I discovered it. If you’re looking for this book or more like it, consider perusing the Equal Opportunity Bookshop, which has two great features; a)it’s not Amazon and b)if you purchase anything from this site’s Bookshop link, we get a little affiliate kickback. Whatever you do, go read something good! Peace!)

[BOOK REVIEW] The Call-Out, by Cat Fitzpatrick

(Buy this book here)

This is a polite comedy of manners set in modern-day queer New York, about 6 women(5 of whom are trans), written entirely in rhyming verse, formatted like an old school LiveJournal blog.

That’s a lot of concept for a 168-page book, and to its credit, it mostly works. Once you get a handle on the character names and the cheeky “look at me I’m LIT-ra-ture!” tone, this is a very clever, readable book.

The title refers to the way we handle moral transgression in community, and the book lampoons the self-righteousness that has become the calling card of call-out culture. One of the characters does something very awkward, thoughtless, uncomfortable, and badly executed–but is it a shunning transgression, or just a stupid misunderstanding? The fallout–and the callout–ruin friendships and fracture community, but also expose the ugliest and most annoying parts of people who see themselves as righteous helpers or objective observers.

Unfortunately, that’s where it loses me a bit. I hesitate to call the characters unlikable –after all, that’s kind of the point–but these women are all really childish and sloppy and unkind. Nobody in this book is good company. It makes for good drama and sometimes good humor, but bad moral fabling. There needs to be at least ONE decent person here, and we don’t get that. Also, one of the problems with call-out culture is its tedium, and that doesn’t change as much as I hoped when fictionalized.

Between this and a few other books I’ve read by trans women set in New York (most notably Detransition, Baby), I’ve come to realize that maybe there’s something really distinctly liminal and volatile and fragile about transgender women’s culture(at least the white girl version) that I’m really not capable of understanding entirely. I still enjoy reading about it, because I appreciate any depiction of #ownnormal life. However, I’m noticing that in these white trans books the tradeoff for full, self-referenced depictions of transness is…very weirdly built women of color. There are two Asian women in this book, and the way they’re depicted had me rolling my eyes a bit, especially the passivity of the Japanese-American woman. I need to read some trans women of color, because this book definitely did them a disservice.

I can’t say I loved this but I did appreciate its cleverness and viewpoint.

Maturity and real honesty to The Call-Out.

(Beautiful people, fellow readers! This is one of the books I like sharing because even though it wasn’t my favorite, it may very well be one of yours. If you want to read more books by trans women, check out my (diverse) booklist. If you’re looking for diverse books in general, check out the Equal Opportunity Bookshop, but remember–any books you purchase there from a link you find here will result in a commission being paid and me buying more books and maintaining this site. It’s capitalism, but…the useful kind, I guess? Before I get myself into some sort of trouble continuing the previous thought, I’d like to say thanks for visiting, and peace! Now go read something good!)

[LAST WEEK IN BOOKS]Biracials, Book Bans, and Billionaires

Look what I’ve had time to do for the first time in ages!

Diverse book news is still thinning on the ground, but because this is reality and not a trend, here’s some links to keep us all up to date;

  • The first one is entirely selfish–I’ve updated the About Me page of this site to include a little bit more about my life as a writer, including a little bibliography of my work(with links!). If you’re curious about what I write outside of reviews and rants, go take a look. [Equal Opportunity Reader]
  • Poet Leila Chatti, a biracial Tunisian-American writer who grew up in a religiously mixed home, has a very thoughtful take on writing while biracial that I learned quite a lot from. [Ploughshares]
  • Jay-Z has donated half a million dollars to fund legal aid for teachers, librarians, and academics facing problems due to book bans. Good for him. [Black Enterprise]
  • Speaking of book bans, I bought what may be the coolest anti-ban shirt ever from friend and online entrepreneur Crafty Kita. It’s the image for this post, and I love it. Also, suck it, book banners. [Crafty Kita]
  • I’ve written before about how reading poetry by justice-impacted people has made me examine my empathy voids. Haitian-American poet Enzo Silon Surin is not, as far as I’m aware, formerly incarcerated, but his new collection examines the social frameworks that make this such a common distress in the Black American community. He elaborates on it all very gracefully in this interview. [The Common]
  • The gamification aspect of Goodreads, Storygraph, and algorithmic sites and apps in general has never bothered me overmuch but I do have concerns for people who’ve had these things all their lives. Turns out they do too. [Shondaland]
  • The Diverse Book Awards longlist is out and…wow. Y’all, I’m slipping, because I haven’t read a single one of these books. To the #tbr they go! [Locus]
  • Henrietta Lacks, immortalized both biologically and literarily, has finally gotten her due. Her family has received financial compensation for the billions of dollars pharmaceutical company Thermo Fisher Scientific has made since 1951, when they harvested Ms. Lacks’ cervical cancer cells. [AP News]
  • Okay, last one–remember all the kerfluffle about Simon and Schuster potentially being bought by Penguin Random House and becoming an enormous Frankenpublisher with even fewer opportunities for fairness and creativity and many more avenues for exploitation and the constant flattening of diversity? Turns out that after that was struck down, Simon and Schuster has still been acquired…by a private equity firm that owns, among other things, Safeway, ToysRUs, and most of the band OneRepublic’s catalog. This will be…interesting. [Wall Street Journal]

That’s it for this week, fellow readers. As always, thanks for reading and if you want to throw a little support this way to keep the blog’s lights on(and enable more of these news posts) please visit the Equal Opportunity Bookshop, where every purchase earns us(me) a little change. Peace! Now go read something good!

[REVIEW] You Had Me At Hola, by Alexis Daria

(Buy this book here.)

Jasmine Lin Rodriguez is an up-and-coming starlet looking to cement her rising career and recover from a bout of bad publicity after being dumped by her rockstar boyfriend. Ashton Suarez is a veteran telenovela heartthrob trying to break into the English language market while keeping his private life hidden from the public. When the two are cast as leads on a new Netflix drama, sparks fly after a very chilly start.

The plot of this book is–ok, listen. I don’t know how many times I’ve said this, but we all know that romance novels all have essentially the same plot, right? Y’all know exactly what happens so I won’t bore you with the play by play here. But I will say that it’s nice to have a story about Hollywood actors that isn’t just a long list of brand names and famous people nonsense. Jasmine and Ashton both have person-next-door charm and they’re genuinely sweet with each other and their communities once the initial misunderstandings have passed. The book also revels in Latinx #ownnormal and interestingly, Jasmine has a Filipina mom but an otherwise Puerto Rican family, which is explored well and comfortably.

I’ve been reading romance novels for decades now, and it’s interesting to see how my perspectives on these stories have grown and changed over the years. The obligatory third act fight and potential breakup is often caused by a lie but in this book, it’s a whopper, despite being a lie of omission, not deceit. Teenage me would have sighed and simpered over Jasmine’s devoted true love and forgiveness but middle-aged me is like “He didn’t tell you WHAT?!? Girl, no! Next!” The resolution of the lie is ok but the fact that it’s there at all annoyed me a bit, and I wanted Jasmine to squeeze Ashton a little more.

In contrast to the plot point lie, the spice level in this book is remarkably grown and I have to say, I like how this book managed to be fairly realistic about grown folk sex without sacrificing any of the heat.

Lumpia con gandules and a smack on the hand for lying to You Had Me At Hola.

(Beautiful people, fellow readers, lovers –thanks for reading! For more diverse romances, check out this booklist on the Equal Opportunity Bookshop page. I really need to update and create some new booklists, but until then, please be aware that if you buy anything from a link you find on this page, I’ll earn a commission. In the meantime, I hope you’re well loved and told the truth wherever you are. Now peace! Go read something good!)

[REVIEW] Camp Zero, by Michelle Min Sterling

(Buy this book here.)

Mixed feelings, thy name is Camp Zero.

The writing is beautiful and tight. Sterling has clearly studied the craft in depth and the book has a technical precision to it that’s really admirable. There were many times in this book when I read a sentence and thought “wow, that’s a beautiful/sharp/moving way to say that”.

The plot is interesting. In a climate-change ravaged near future, sex worker Rose is sent to Canada’s Camp Zero by a former patron to keep an eye on the head architect. He thinks he’s building a school, a haven away from extreme weather patterns. The odd behavior of the camp employees, including the school’s new professor Grant, points to something far more sinister. Meanwhile, an unnamed narrator occasionally details a creepy story of a remote military outpost that may or may not be connected to it all.

It’s hard to take modern eco-fiction seriously once you’ve read Octavia Butler’s Parables, I think. Rehashing points made by forward thinkers in the late 90s only highlights how little imagination and motivation we currently have as a society when it comes to finding solutions for the troubled future we’ve created for ourselves. This book wants to be an interrogation of climate change’s impact on society, but instead, it just wallows in the same self-centered doom that got us here to begin with.

Also, I was bored or annoyed by a lot of the tropes and character cliches in this, including;

  • Mixed Asian/white protagonist as exoticized sex worker trying to rescue her poor refugee mother
  • Sad rich white boy who treats women hatefully tries to redeem himself through teaching the poors and pretending he doesn’t have money
  • Angry sort-of-feminist scientists who rob and murder men but it’s okay because all men are creeps
  • Random white girl indulging in literal savagery, but it’s okay because she’s special
  • Weird white fetish-ridden billionaire is actually smart and desirable instead of just weird
  • Only one Black person in the future, who has no purpose outside of being described as Black at the beginning of the book and never mentioned again
  • Also no Indigenous folks, even though this clearly takes place on their (ironically) acknowledged land.

sigh

There are a lot of places where the writing shines past these things, but overall the book is just a bit socially oblivious, which is the exact opposite of what it’s trying to be. Add that to the tumbledown ending and the overall effect is one of “girl, I guess.”

Hope and optimism to Camp Zero.

(Beautiful people! This dystopia didn’t have enough imagination for me, but if you want to check out a list of diverse dystopias that go far beyond the limitations of our present inequal reality, check out this booklist at the Equal Opportunity Bookshop. Any purchase made from a link you find on this site will result in a commission being paid, which I use to buy more books that I then review in the hopes of getting you to buy more books. It’s a beautiful life cycle. In the meantime, whether or not you click a link, go and read something good. Peace!)

[REVIEW] Elite Capture, by Olúfémi O. Táíwò

(Buy this book here.)

I think at this point we all realize that this idea many millennials have been fed of working really hard, socially climbing, and getting into powerful rooms and important tables to make changes is more or less a pipe dream. It’s not that it isn’t possible, it’s just that it’s not always an effective strategy for real and lasting change. In other words, working to become a decision-maker often isn’t what it’s cracked up to be.

Aside from the inefficiency, there’s also the frustration. While you’re working hard to gain access to elite spaces and the power they bring, other people are allowed to casually walk in the room with a few loud, dumb ideas and thrive. You’re exhausted and out of your comfort zone, while they’re complicit and entitled. This is not a recipe for success. The social pressures of gaining class levels and fitting in to higher education spaces may inadvertently rob you of your authentic voice. The pressure of being “the only one” may even be used to get you to speak out on behalf of communities you don’t even know just so that someone will.

None of this is ideal, and if you think about it, it means that there’s a much more important question to ask than “how do we gain power”. It’s “how do we change power?”, which is what Táíwò asks in this book.

In one small, dense volume (only 5 chapters), he draws on examples from the US, Cape Verde, and Brazil to break down how the politics of identity have been used and misused to reinforce existing power, rather than empower everyone. There’s a lot of discussion of what’s wrong and how it got that way, but fortunately, it doesn’t stop there. There’s also a lot of discussion of what needs to change and some excellent examples of how the commodification of elitism has been called out and tackled head-on in history in several places. How things could change–as in, step by step solution possibilities–is not discussed quite as expansively (although there’s some great info about Flint, Michigan) but I feel like that’s another book entirely–and I hope Táíwò writes it.

The writing starts out pretty dry but picks up the pace quickly once it gets into recounting examples and steps away from foundational theory. Táíwò also stays away from jargon and jingoism and those tired-ass meme racial justice talking points that have taken over the world to make “allies” feel correct, which is a relief. This is real work, not commodification of activism or progressive political and social stances.

Even if you’re not a big non-fiction reader, this book is worth a read if you’re working towards a shift in position, class or access to power–or if you’re uncomfortable with what’s expected of you to maintain the class, position, or access to power that you were bequeathed. At least check out the excerpt of it in Boston Review.

Fuller equity and a better ideological house with good theoretical and practical roommates to Elite Capture.

(Beautiful people! Thanks for reading. I try and balance my political/social non-fiction reviews with plenty of fiction on this site for a variety of reasons, but if you want to see more of my non-fiction recommendations, check out my Ten For The Times booklist. Also check out the other lists on offer in the Equal Opportuity Bookshop. Just remember that if you buy anything there using a link you find here, I earn a commission–which I promptly use to buy more books. Peace! Now, go and read something good!)

[REVIEW] Yellowface, by R.F. Kuang

(Buy this book here.)

I got a little tired of being the last blogger on the internet who hadn’t read this book, so I finally picked up a copy and packed it in my carry-on for an overnight flight.

I had to sleep. I knew I had to sleep. I still stayed up and finished this whole book and showed up in Frankfurt Airport (a.k.a. air transit purgatory) seriously grumpy and sleep-deprived.

Yellowface is quite a departure for R.F. Kuang. It’s literary fiction–almost a thriller–and she’s known for her fantasy novels, like the Poppy War series(I previously reviewed The Poppy War and The Dragon Republic in all their bone-breaking life-taking glory) and the alternate Oxford takedown of colonialism with word magic, Babel. But when everything an author writes is a best-seller, departures and experimentation are encouraged so, Yellowface is a literary novel criticizing the publishing industry.

I think what fascinates me about this book is its audacity. It lays bare what those of us who pay close attention to the world of books and writers already know; behind the scenes, commercial publishing is skewed towards whiteness, and often white femininity. This book dives into the nasty spaces behind the scenes. Everyone’s an ally, yet acclaimed writers who aren’t white collect marginal advances compared to their unknown, whiter, more “marketable” counterparts. High-profile writers of color are creatively marginalized into expected narratives. Cultural pain and authenticity are reduced to entertaining commodities. Jealousy, loneliness, and competition mar creativity and connection. Yellowface pulls very few punches and kills quite a lot of self-righteous industry darlings.

And it does it all by working very hard to try and make you empathize with June Hayward, who may be the most Casually Awful White Woman In The World. June witnesses her frenemy, impossibly cool Asian author Athena Liu, die in a freak accident. Somehow Athena’s work in progress finds its way into June’s possession and after revising it to her taste, she passes it off as her own and brands herself as vaguely Asian to market it. The resulting roller coaster of guilt, accusations, and dirty deals feels scarily realistic and grimy.

It’s a light but complex read–Kuang can still write her ass off and that’s on full display here. The ending was a bit pat for me, but the nuance infused into the characters was fascinating. Everyone’s awful, but everyone’s sad, too. Sometimes the people who create beautiful things are living deeply isolated, envious lives. Sometimes your friends really can’t be trusted–even after death.

I don’t even know what to give Yellowface. Discomfort? Useless DEI training? A support group?

(Beautiful people, this book is a trip. I’ve read very little like it but I hope more is coming. For more diverse books for diverse readers, please check out the Equal Opportunity Bookshop, where we earn a commission for any books you purchase through our links. By ‘we’, I mean me, and since I have books to read, I’ll end today’s note here. Peace! Now go read something good!)